“Problem solving” is a term borrowed from Life Space Crisis Intervention. At the Regional Support Centre where I worked, it became our term for talking. Many of our kids came to us with negative mindsets about talking. When we used the word “talk,” most kids heard “lecture,” or “scold,” or “trouble.” When we said it was time to “problem-solve,” the response was different. They soon learned this meant that they would get to tell their side of the story and it would be listened to without judgment. They also learned that they had a pretty good shot at resolving the problem.
I will not attempt to explain the ideas of Dr. Long and Dr. Wood. I wholeheartedly recommend that you learn about Life Space Crisis Intervention for yourself. What I will do is tell you what LSCI means for me.
One of the things I lacked early in my career was an idea of who I needed to be during a student’s crisis. I assumed my job was that of moral thermometer. I felt the kids often lacked clear ideas about right and wrong and I can remember listening to kids tell me stories while I reminded myself to look disapproving. I actually distracted myself from being a good listener, because I thought it was my job to frown or cluck my tongue when the story got to the part about sneaking out the bedroom window or slashing a tire or running away from the police. I thought the kids would interpret a neutral face as condoning their behaviour.
LSCI changed that completely. It requires that I be present with kids when they are upset, help them be calm enough to talk, and listen to their story with no judgment. That is the first phase. After that, I will use questions and clarification to determine the details of the events as clearly as possible. Last, I will determine what the situation calls for, choose a direction to move in, and assist the students to see the meaning behind their actions. Hopefully, the result is learning for the students, about their patterns of behaviour, about how those patterns negatively affect their lives, about how they can work to change them. Sometimes, it takes a lot of problem solving just to help a student see the pattern and then a whole lot more to begin to address it. The point is, LSCI provides a framework to use and a role for the adult to play. Knowing my role in dealing with kids was something more like counsellor, coach, or friend, was far more appealing to me than Dispenser of Justice. When I began to use LSCI, I was amazed to find that once kids had worked through a problem with me and had even been able to see their contribution to the problem, they were far more willing to discuss consequences.
Monica is the author of "Thanks for chucking that at the wall instead of me."
Monica is an educator and writer who is endlessly fascinated with human behaviour in all its wonderous shapes and colours.
Monday, May 11, 2009
Wednesday, March 4, 2009
Conflict (part 2)
As mentioned in the first part of this discussion, I needed to do some learning to move from my mindset of conflict as detour to conflict as benefit. The first thing I had to learn was that the only person I can control in a conflict situation is myself. Seems a simple concept, doesn’t it?
After dealing with a conflict, I would go over it again in my head—the intellectual process as well as the emotional one—and I soon recognized how much energy I expended trying to control the student’s behaviour and choices. When I finally internalized that I had no control over their part, I was able to relax more, listen better, and ironically, outcomes immediately started to be more positive. I focused on staying present: as I trained myself to stop mapping the route of the discussion and just let it unfold, my instincts became more actively involved.
Next, I learned about conflict styles: passive, assertive, aggressive.
Some of these styles work well together to resolve conflicts – two assertive people will have a positive resolution in no time. However, an aggressive and a passive person will likely have very brief conflicts which appear to be over quickly and easily, but they will have an ongoing pattern of the same types of conflicts over and over in high frequency. This is because the passive person is backing down, apologizing, making it better, and the issue is buried, but not dead.
Because I knew I could be aggressive when not mindful, I practiced very concrete behaviours in conflict situations. For example, because the other participant was usually smaller than me, I would sit or kneel down if possible. Because I had a tendency to point (not good for kids with hair triggers), I sometimes put my hands in my pockets. Because I knew I could get loud, I tried to lower my voice right away.
Incidentally, people in conflict tend to mirror the behaviour of the other person, which means the more mindful participant (read: adult) needs to make sure they do not mirror aggressive behaviours of angry kids and be mindful of what the other participant is seeing in the mirror. (Try this sometime with anyone you find too loud: Talk softly and slowly and watch them relax and talk more quietly.)
Know your style and adjust for it. If you are passive, push yourself forward, if you are aggressive, hold yourself back. Whatever the child’s style, keep it in mind and don’t be detoured by style over content.
Stress is a huge contributor to conflict situations and we all experience stress of different kinds. Developmental stress: birth to death and everything in between! Potty training, training bras, bra burning, burning urination . . . developmental stress is constant in the growing and learning process. Sometimes we forget how much this is contributing to conflicts that arise with kids. Psychological stress: what kids believe about themselves. This is a factor for many kids and how “irrational beliefs” get in their heads can be pretty mystifying but it happens all the time. I had a student tell the class that when he was little, he believed that being sent to his room meant that his mom did not love him anymore. Reality stress: things go wrong in daily life! Here’s where celebrating mistakes and not getting caught up in perfection can relieve stress for kids. Some kids are stressed out by any mistake they make. Physical stress: tired, sick, sore, growing!
Understanding how these impacted me helped me to monitor myself in conflict situations: “Give this a little extra thought – you didn’t get enough sleep last night.” It also gave me a little extra compassion for the student and a bit more help in depersonalizing the aggressive behaviour that was probably not so much about me at all.
Finally, I learned about how the conflict cycle works. I learned what was happening so that I could step outside of it and see it as an entity outside myself. I could say, “Oh, this student is experiencing a stressful incident I am unaware of and their feelings have created a negative behaviour directed at me. I will not respond to the negative behaviour but will use my impressive skills to determine what created the initial stress and address it first, thus de-stressing the child, creating a stronger bond between us and finally, addressing the negative behaviour in a calm, supportive manner.”
Well, maybe it didn’t go exactly like that. Maybe it was more like, “Don’t yell! Find out what’s really going on and then you can punish him later!” Incidentally, by the time we worked through the conflict, I never felt like punishing them. I usually felt more like hugging them. And while they started out on the attack, they were more likely than I to bring up the topic of restitution.
Conflict can be positive. The details of working through the conflict will vary from one helping adult to another. At the Centre, we used a method called Problem-solving. But that’s a topic for another day. Or another post.
If you want to read more about this view of conflict, please check out chapters four and five of Thanks for chucking that at the wall instead of me.
Monica is the author of "Thanks for chucking that at the wall instead of me."
After dealing with a conflict, I would go over it again in my head—the intellectual process as well as the emotional one—and I soon recognized how much energy I expended trying to control the student’s behaviour and choices. When I finally internalized that I had no control over their part, I was able to relax more, listen better, and ironically, outcomes immediately started to be more positive. I focused on staying present: as I trained myself to stop mapping the route of the discussion and just let it unfold, my instincts became more actively involved.
Next, I learned about conflict styles: passive, assertive, aggressive.
Some of these styles work well together to resolve conflicts – two assertive people will have a positive resolution in no time. However, an aggressive and a passive person will likely have very brief conflicts which appear to be over quickly and easily, but they will have an ongoing pattern of the same types of conflicts over and over in high frequency. This is because the passive person is backing down, apologizing, making it better, and the issue is buried, but not dead.
Because I knew I could be aggressive when not mindful, I practiced very concrete behaviours in conflict situations. For example, because the other participant was usually smaller than me, I would sit or kneel down if possible. Because I had a tendency to point (not good for kids with hair triggers), I sometimes put my hands in my pockets. Because I knew I could get loud, I tried to lower my voice right away.
Incidentally, people in conflict tend to mirror the behaviour of the other person, which means the more mindful participant (read: adult) needs to make sure they do not mirror aggressive behaviours of angry kids and be mindful of what the other participant is seeing in the mirror. (Try this sometime with anyone you find too loud: Talk softly and slowly and watch them relax and talk more quietly.)
Know your style and adjust for it. If you are passive, push yourself forward, if you are aggressive, hold yourself back. Whatever the child’s style, keep it in mind and don’t be detoured by style over content.
Stress is a huge contributor to conflict situations and we all experience stress of different kinds. Developmental stress: birth to death and everything in between! Potty training, training bras, bra burning, burning urination . . . developmental stress is constant in the growing and learning process. Sometimes we forget how much this is contributing to conflicts that arise with kids. Psychological stress: what kids believe about themselves. This is a factor for many kids and how “irrational beliefs” get in their heads can be pretty mystifying but it happens all the time. I had a student tell the class that when he was little, he believed that being sent to his room meant that his mom did not love him anymore. Reality stress: things go wrong in daily life! Here’s where celebrating mistakes and not getting caught up in perfection can relieve stress for kids. Some kids are stressed out by any mistake they make. Physical stress: tired, sick, sore, growing!
Understanding how these impacted me helped me to monitor myself in conflict situations: “Give this a little extra thought – you didn’t get enough sleep last night.” It also gave me a little extra compassion for the student and a bit more help in depersonalizing the aggressive behaviour that was probably not so much about me at all.
Finally, I learned about how the conflict cycle works. I learned what was happening so that I could step outside of it and see it as an entity outside myself. I could say, “Oh, this student is experiencing a stressful incident I am unaware of and their feelings have created a negative behaviour directed at me. I will not respond to the negative behaviour but will use my impressive skills to determine what created the initial stress and address it first, thus de-stressing the child, creating a stronger bond between us and finally, addressing the negative behaviour in a calm, supportive manner.”
Well, maybe it didn’t go exactly like that. Maybe it was more like, “Don’t yell! Find out what’s really going on and then you can punish him later!” Incidentally, by the time we worked through the conflict, I never felt like punishing them. I usually felt more like hugging them. And while they started out on the attack, they were more likely than I to bring up the topic of restitution.
Conflict can be positive. The details of working through the conflict will vary from one helping adult to another. At the Centre, we used a method called Problem-solving. But that’s a topic for another day. Or another post.
If you want to read more about this view of conflict, please check out chapters four and five of Thanks for chucking that at the wall instead of me.
Monica is the author of "Thanks for chucking that at the wall instead of me."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)